The Right Order, Every Time
- 01Photograph everything before the carrier leaves, and have the BOL reflect it. If possible, also photograph the trailer bed before loading to establish pre-existing condition.
- 02Notify the broker and the carrier within 24 hours in writing (email beats phone; check the claim clause in your contract for the exact window, often 24h-30 days). Include photos, BOL, and the damage item list.
- 03Get a repair estimate from a body shop before the claim goes stale; carriers respond faster to a documented number than to "my car is scratched".
- 04Demand the claim reference number in writing from the insurer, not just from the dispatcher. No claim number, no paper trail; follow up weekly in writing.
- 05If the carrier goes silent, escalate: BBB complaint (public visibility), FMCSA NCCDB (formal), Small Claims Court (fast money for small damage), FCBA chargeback if payment was by card, and BMC-84 bond claim as last resort.
Three Settlement Patterns You Actually See
- ·Fast settlement: carrier accepts, repair at approved shop, pay deductible, done in 30-90 days. Most common when BOL is clean and coverage is real.
- ·Partial payout: insurer pays repair minus deductible or capped at stated limit; you negotiate or accept; common when damage is documented but coverage is thin.
- ·Denial and demand letter: carrier denies or goes quiet; you escalate with a demand citing the Carmack Amendment (49 U.S.C. § 14706) and your contract; small-claims judgment is the usual endpoint for cargo under $10k.
Read the claim window in your contract before you sign. Any time beyond it is a refusal your own lawyer will not unwind. Carmack Amendment cases against carriers are commonly filed within 9 months of delivery (federal rule of limitations); do not sit on your rights. This page is not legal advice.