CarFreight Review, independent auto transport research
HOME/GUIDES/DAMAGE CLAIMS
WORKFLOW NOT LITIGATION
FIELD GUIDE // CLAIMS WORKFLOW

FILE ON TIME,
FILE IN WRITING.

The claim is won or lost in the first 14 days, not in court six months later. Here is the order to follow, the documents that matter, and the three settlement paths you actually see, with timing from what companies publish and consumers report in 2026.

The Right Order, Every Time

  1. 01Photograph everything before the carrier leaves, and have the BOL reflect it. If possible, also photograph the trailer bed before loading to establish pre-existing condition.
  2. 02Notify the broker and the carrier within 24 hours in writing (email beats phone; check the claim clause in your contract for the exact window, often 24h-30 days). Include photos, BOL, and the damage item list.
  3. 03Get a repair estimate from a body shop before the claim goes stale; carriers respond faster to a documented number than to "my car is scratched".
  4. 04Demand the claim reference number in writing from the insurer, not just from the dispatcher. No claim number, no paper trail; follow up weekly in writing.
  5. 05If the carrier goes silent, escalate: BBB complaint (public visibility), FMCSA NCCDB (formal), Small Claims Court (fast money for small damage), FCBA chargeback if payment was by card, and BMC-84 bond claim as last resort.

Three Settlement Patterns You Actually See

  • ·Fast settlement: carrier accepts, repair at approved shop, pay deductible, done in 30-90 days. Most common when BOL is clean and coverage is real.
  • ·Partial payout: insurer pays repair minus deductible or capped at stated limit; you negotiate or accept; common when damage is documented but coverage is thin.
  • ·Denial and demand letter: carrier denies or goes quiet; you escalate with a demand citing the Carmack Amendment (49 U.S.C. § 14706) and your contract; small-claims judgment is the usual endpoint for cargo under $10k.
Read the claim window in your contract before you sign. Any time beyond it is a refusal your own lawyer will not unwind. Carmack Amendment cases against carriers are commonly filed within 9 months of delivery (federal rule of limitations); do not sit on your rights. This page is not legal advice.