CarFreight Review, independent auto transport research
HOME / CORRECTIONS / POLICY & RIGHT OF REPLY
POLICY REV. 2026-11 GOVERNS ALL PAGES NOT LEGAL ADVICE
ERRATA & RIGHT OF REPLY // BINDING ON CARFREIGHT.REVIEW

WE PUBLISH ERRATA, NOT EXCUSES.

Every page on this site carries this protocol: what counts as an error, what evidence we require to change something, how fast we act, and exactly how a named company gets its rebuttal published unedited. If we got something wrong, say so with documents; we correct in the open, in place, and we log the change publicly.

gavel BEFORE ANY CLAIM, SUIT, DEMAND OR THREAT OF LITIGATION

If you believe any statement on this site is false, you must first send a written notice to legal@carfreight.review with subject line "LEGAL NOTICE" identifying: (1) the exact page URL; (2) the exact statement verbatim; (3) the specific facts or primary documents you contend are false, with copies; (4) the correction you propose; and (5) your contact details and authority to act for the claimant. We have 30 calendar days from receipt to review and either publish the correction with attribution, or notify you in writing of the specific reason(s) the claim fails. Filing suit before this notice and 30-day review period forfeits nothing you already have, but in most U.S. jurisdictions a publisher's timely correction materially limits or eliminates presumed and punitive damages against them, including under state retraction statutes (see RCFP, Pro Journalism & Defamation).

This page is not a retraction statute itself, does not bind any court, and does not waive your rights or ours. We are not lawyers; this is not legal advice; consult qualified counsel in your jurisdiction. Nothing here restricts lawful reporting of non-confidential public records, commentary, opinion, or criticism of public companies.

Three Doors, Three Queues

Pick the door that matches what you have. Using the wrong one only slows your case down.

fact_check Door 1

Correct a Fact

Any factual error on any page: a wrong USDOT/MC, a wrong bond status, an outdated rating, an incorrect date, a mislabeled entity.

newsroom@carfreight.review → Use this door with documents; opinions go to Door 2
gavel Door 2

Right of Reply (Companies)

The named company answers the record on the same page. Published verbatim with attribution; authority verified from registry-grade evidence only.

rebuttal@carfreight.review → Verification: official domain email or registry-linked officer signature
mail_lock Door 3

Legal Notices

Retraction demands, subpoenas, DMCA takedowns, RFPs, service of process. No consumer complaints; no disputes with carriers; no PR pitches.

legal@carfreight.review → 30-day written-review window applies (see above)

02 // Evidence Standards: What Counts as Proof

Primary Sources Only

We do not correct records on the strength of a company's say-so, a PR firm's letterhead or a lawyer's bluster. We do not correct them on the strength of a consumer's say-so either. We correct on the strength of documents that any reader can go read, ideally with a stable URL and retrieval date.

ACCEPTED (STRONG)
  • ✓FMCSA SAFER and Licensing & Insurance pages for the named USDOT/MC, captured with URL and date.
  • ✓BMC-84 bond evidence naming surety, policy, effective/received dates, cancellation notice if applicable.
  • ✓BBB profile pages (file number, URL, date) including complaint counts and rating letter as displayed.
  • ✓Final court or agency orders, on docket, naming the entity.
  • ✓Typed corrections filed by the company's officers, signed on company letterhead, matching the registry official for that USDOT/MC.
NOT SUFFICIENT (WEAK)
  • ✗Screenshots without source URL, timestamp, or file number.
  • ✗"Verified" marketing badges ("Google 4.7 · 67,926 reviews" and the like); marketing claims are labeled, not adopted.
  • ✗Declarations of satisfaction with no document attached; we take instruction from regulators, not from plaintiffs.
  • ✗Requests to remove a page because a carrier "doesn't like it". Removals are for errors and for law; not for comfort.
  • ✗Legal threats delivered by social media or SEO consultants; they are routed to Door 3 and answered with this page.

If you cannot attach a primary document, that is not a flaw in our policy. It only means we cannot re-verify the claim. We will say "not verified" publicly rather than guess, and the affected profile will say exactly what is unverified, by whom, and as of when.

03 // From Intake to Publication: The Five Steps

5 Steps · Written Outcomes
  1. 1Receipt. Within 5 business days of a complete filing we confirm the docket number and who will review it. Incomplete filings are rejected the same day with a written deficiency list.
  2. 2Verification. We re-read the primary source ourselves. Where the claim is "our bond is active", we go to L&I; where the claim is "our rating is A+", we go to BBB; where the claim is "we are a motor carrier", we go to SAFER. We never skip this.
  3. 3Decision. Within 14 business days of a complete filing we decide: CORRECTED / CLARIFIED / NOT SUBSTANTIATED. You receive the decision in writing with the reviewer's note.
  4. 4Publication. Within 14 calendar days of decision, the change is made in place, an ERRATA note is appended to the affected page(s) with date and nature of change, and the public Corrections Log is updated. Headlines change too when material.
  5. 5Appeal. If your claim fails and you disagree, you may appeal once, with new evidence or a clear error of process, within 30 days of the decision. One appeal per filing. The appeal goes to a different reviewer.

Missed deadlines do not convert us into your PR firm or into your adversary. A missed SLA buys you status emails and a dated promise of the next decision checkpoint, nothing more; a meritorious document does not wait for a calendar.

04 // The Right of Reply, Step by Step

Companies Named in a Dossier

Every company we profile is automatically entitled to this. You do not need to ask twice, and your reply is never conditioned on agreeing with us about anything.

  1. 1Identification check. Email from the company's domain, or a letter signed by the official listed in the FMCSA/L&I record for that USDOT/MC, or the signatory of the company's filed terms. This kills nothing; it only proves you are them.
  2. 2Your answer. You answer specific statements by ID in the dossier, in writing, up to 2,000 words, plus exhibits (documents, links). We publish it verbatim, attributed: "Right of Reply, [Company], published [date]": no edits to substance, no requirement that you accept our wording, no usage fees.
  3. 3Our side remains. Your reply does not replace the dossier; it sits beneath it, permanently. A reader must be able to see both what we said about you and what you said about us on the same page.
  4. 4Silent is a status too. If we receive no verified reply within 30 days of publication, the dossier will say "No reply on file" going forward. Silence is disclosed, never hidden.

05 // What We Will Never Publish or Accept

The Guardrails
  • No labels of criminality"Fraud", "scammer", "criminal", "racketeer" applied to an unconvicted company or person, from a complaint we cannot criminally verify. Those words appear only inside attributed quotes or lawful reporting with court orders.
  • No private individuals' private livesWe do not publish home addresses, personal phones, family, medical, financial or social information of company staff. Registry officials' names appear because they are public registry data, cited as such.
  • No ratings or verdictsWe do not score, rank or grade companies. Counts of complaints are attention markers, not findings of fault.
  • No fabricated casesEvery complaint count is BBB-published; every repricing quote links a profile dossier with documents read on the dates stated. If a case is not documented, it does not exist here.
  • No unverified consumer narrativesWe do not republish individual complaint texts; consumers go to BBB and FMCSA NCCDB; we publish attribution, not allegations.
  • No pay-for-placement, no strikesCompanies do not pay us, and paying us to change a dossier is precisely what Door 3 is for. A check to a newsroom is not a legal notice.

06 // Public Errata Log

Every Correction, In the Open

We do not quietly edit history. Each material change gets a line here, with the date, the page, the nature of the change and the reason. This log is the standing proof that the policy is real, not a shield we keep in a drawer.

Date (EST) Page(s) Change & reason
2026-11-15complaintsFabricated case files and auditor names removed; page rebuilt as an index of BBB-published 3-year complaint counts for the 31 researched profiles (read 11/13–15/2026). Reason: invented evidentiary claims are the definition of an error.
2026-11-15investigationsFabricated "8-month audit of 1,240 shipments" removed; page rebuilt as CR-2026-11 "The Repricing Economy" with 16 attributed sources (SGT 2026, EIA, FMCSA eCFR, D. Del. opinion, etc.). Reason: no underlying data existed.
2026-11-15calculatorStitch mock with invented "AUDITED RATE DOSSIER", dead PDF and false "$0 Upfront Deposit Rule" removed; rebuilt as a sourced 2026 estimator (SGT distance bands, EIA diesel $6.127, documented seasonality). Reason: invented benchmarks.
2026-11-15seasonal ratesFabricated "ANNUAL RATE MULTIPLIERS" table (invented monthly prices) replaced with attributed 2026 seasonality (Corsia, RoadRunner/InterstateMovingNow, Rapid dispatch index, Direct Connect PCS, EIA). Reason: invented data.
2026-11-15pricingInvented "$0.62–$1.15/mi audited" and fake "1,840 CLEARED LOADS", "N=2,410", corridor table and quote waterfall replaced with SGT/Move.org/MoveAdvisor/RoadRunner 2026 benchmarks, all cited; terminology verified. Reason: invented benchmarks and audits.
2026-11-15reviewseasy-cargo-ship/L&I read added: USDOT 4532166 MC-1797225 Inactive; USDOT 3149259 MC-103888 Inactive; both BMC-84 bonds canceled (Amherst Nat'l 7/23/2026; American Alt. Ins. 6/5/2026); officials Joseph Reynoso (Owner) and Eric Ray Gallite (CEO). Reason: record was unread at publication; status corrected to what the records show.
2026-11-15reviewsauto-shipping-group/Mojibake (·) in 15 locations replaced with intended '·' glyph. Reason: encoding error.
2026-11-15reviewsStitch mock pagination ("1,420 entity types", "142 MATCHING PROFILES") removed; directory rebuilt with 31 real profiles, working search/filters/pagination. Reason: invented counts and non-functional controls.

Entries appear when a change ships. This log is maintained editorially; requests to add or strike lines use Door 1 (newsroom@carfreight.review) and are resolved under this same policy.

07 // What This Page Is Not

Out of Scope, Plainly
Not legal, financial, insurance or tax adviceWe publish research; you act on your own judgment and counsel. This policy protects the accuracy of the record, not your transaction.
Not a consumer complaint intakeDisputes between you and a carrier/broker go to BBB (www.bbb.org) and FMCSA NCCDB (nccdb.fmcsa.dot.gov). We will not mediate, arbitrate or collect evidence for your case.
Not a place to buy goodwillWe do not trade corrections, favorable framing or deletions for advertising, affiliate revenue, "partnership" or review scores. If you want one of those, Door 3 is the correct door.
Not a contract with readersThis policy binds Carfreight.review's conduct, creates no warranties to third parties, and may be updated with an ERRATA note; it does not waive or limit any rights you have at law.
Not an admissionA correction means we got a fact wrong and we fix it; it is not an admission of fault for any other purpose, and it does not create liability beyond the corrected record.
Not a reporting obligation overrideWe are not a law enforcement agency; we do not investigate crimes; we report what public registries and filings show, and what they do not show, attributed as such.

Copyright, Trademarks & Quoting This Site

Logos and trademarks shown on this site (FMCSA, DOT and other marks and company logos) are the property of their respective owners. They are shown solely for identification and commentary under nominative fair use; no association with or endorsement by those owners is implied.

Quoting this site is permitted with attribution: "Carfreight.review, [page title], [date read]." Direct, linked quotes are welcome for journalism, research and due diligence. Systematic scraping for training corpora or SEO cloaking is not.

CONTACT FOR LEGAL NOTICES

legal@carfreight.review

Subject line "LEGAL NOTICE - [USDOT/MC/date]". Subpoenas must name the document(s) requested and your docket number; informal demands get this page back.

Carfreight.review Research Desk · Corrections Policy Rev. 2026-11 · November 2026