CarFreight Review, independent auto transport research
HOME / STANDARDS / METHODOLOGY
REV. 2026-11 SPJ CODE OF ETHICS SELF-APPLIED, NOT CERTIFIED
STANDARD: SPJ CODE OF ETHICS + ATTRIBUTION MANDATE PRIMARY FEDERAL RECORDS, READ LIVE NO RATED SCORES, EVER
fact_check SECTION 00 // HOW WE DO THE WORK

HOW WE RESEARCH. WHAT WE VERIFY. WHAT WE DON'T CLAIM.

This page is the contract between this publication and its readers. It states exactly which records we read, in which order, against which primary sources, how conflicts get reported instead of resolved, what we will never print, and what we will never, ever, claim to be. Read it before trusting any profile on this site, including ours.

verified_user
THE NEGATIVE PLEDGE. We do not score, rank, rate or certify companies. We do not sell research. We accept no payments, placements or referrals from any company we profile, ever. We publish no consumer complaint narratives we have not individually read and verified, because we do not claim to have verified them.

01 // What We Read, In the Order We Read It

Every Source, Every Profile

A Carfreight profile exists only when we have completed this sequence. Skipping steps produces a page we do not publish, no matter how favorable or unfavorable the result seems.

Source What We Extract What It Proves What It Never Proves
FMCSA SAFER snapshot
safer.fmcsa.dot.gov
Legal name, DBA, USDOT, MC/FF number, entity type (broker/carrier/freight forwarder), physical & mailing address, phone, MCS-150 date, operating status, Hazmat, power units The company existed as a registered entity on the read date, under the name and authority shown That it is solvent, honest, timely, or still active tomorrow; SAFER is a snapshot, not real-time truth
FMCSA L&I pages (account + authority detail)
li.fmcsa.dot.gov
Authority type and current status, filing date received/effective, BMC-84 (brokers, $75,000) or BMC-91X (carriers) policy number, surety, officials listed, revocation history, addresses and contacts Bond/insurance was on file with FMCSA as of the read date; revocation and reinstatement history; who the agency lists as officials That the bond will pay a claim; that officials listed today still run the company tomorrow; that the authority will never be revoked
BBB company file (with file number and read dates)
bbb.org
Rating letter, accreditation history, complaints in 3 years and in last 12 months (with types), reviews count, business started, ownership/management from BBB What consumers filed and what BBB displays as of the read date That the complaints are valid; that the company is at fault; that ratings cause anything; complaints are counts, not verdicts
Company publications
home / about / contact / terms / privacy
Legal name as published, addresses and phones, registration claims, advertised services, cancellation and refund terms, liability clauses, arbitration, dispute venues, guarantees What the company says about itself, under its own signature, in its own words That any of it is true; that terms are enforceable; that "A+ rated" on the homepage is BBB-verified; company publications are attributed, never adopted
State registrations & press releases
SoS records; company releases; EIN announcements
Legal existence, registered agent, incumbency, dates of formation or dissolution, business locations What the state shows on the read date Truthfulness of self-promotional claims ("founded 2008" vs FMCSA MCS-150 registered 2024); conflicts are reported, never resolved for them
Consumer platforms
Trustpilot, ConsumerAffairs, Yelp, TransportReviews
Displayed counts, claimed or unclaimed status, claim dates, review themes in that platform's own words What that platform displays as of the read date Accuracy, completeness, or representativeness. Platform counts differ wildly and are shown side by side, never averaged into one number

02 // Tiers of Evidence, Ranked

Stronger to Weaker

When two sources disagree, we publish both and label the stronger. We never average them, never pick the one we like, and never treat the disagreement as resolved. The tier only tells you whose documentation you can rely on, first.

TIER 1 · FEDERAL PRIMARY RECORDS

SAFER snapshots; FMCSA L&I (account and authority detail); FMCSA Final Rules and Federal Register notices; eCFR. These are the only records we treat as dispositive of legal status at the read date.

TIER 2 · COMPANY-PUBLISHED RECORDS

Home, about, contact, terms, privacy, insurance pages; press releases; EIN announcements; profile claim edits. Read, quoted and attributed, always labeled company-published.

TIER 3 · REGULATED COURTESY RECORDS

BBB files (with file number and read dates), NCCDB category counts, state SoS registrations. BBB complaints are reported as displayed, not adjudicated; NCCDB counts are directional.

TIER 4 · THIRD-PARTY AGGREGATES

Trustpilot, ConsumerAffairs, Yelp, TransportReviews. Counted as displayed, side by side, with claimed vs unclaimed status. Never merged into a single "score".

TIER 5 · OUR ANALYSIS, LABELED AS SUCH

Inferences about behavior from documented patterns (repricing examples, bond cancellations, revocation history). Always introduced as analysis, always separately from records, always reversible if records change. Never dressed as findings of fact, never adjudicated as misconduct.

03 // The Five-Step Verification Sequence

Per Profile, Every Time
01

Authority Validation

SAFER lookup by MC/USDOT: legal name, DBA, authority type, entity. If no record matches, we say so, and we say exactly what we checked. No mirror records, no guessing.

02

Bond & Filing Audit

L&I authority detail for brokers (BMC-84 / $75,000) and carriers (BMC-91X): surety name, policy number, received and effective dates, revocation or reinstatement history.

03

Identity & Conflicts

Legal name vs DBA vs BBB name vs site name. Sister registrations, dual addresses, phone mismatches, officials in SAFER vs BBB vs terms. All conflicts reported, never reconciled for them.

04

Dispute Vector Audit

BBB complaints (3-year and last 12 months) as published, with types and company responses, one by one. We count what is displayed; we display what the company said, too.

05

Attributed Synthesis

Every material statement carries attribution ("FMCSA SAFER, data as of 11/13/2026"). Conflicting identifiers stay on the page. Analysis is labeled "Research findings"; raw records are "Source", always separated.

EVERY FACT ON A PROFILE IS CHECKED AGAINST ITS OWN LINK. A profile that fails Steps 01 or 02 is not published at any price, for any company, even one we like.

04 // What We Don't Claim

Negative Commitments
Not an FMCSA auditWe are not FMCSA, not a state agency, not a surety, not a court. A clean profile page is not a safety certificate; a dirty one is not a sanction.
No scores, ratings, grades, verdictsWe publish counts, dates, documents, and attributed words. If you want a grade, we are the wrong site, deliberately.
No consumer-advocacy relationshipReading a profile does not make us your agent, lawyer, insurer or investigator. We do not collect deposits, evidence, or case files on anyone's behalf.
No guarantee of freshnessSAFER data ages; L&I changes silently; BBB prints different numbers on different days. Every figure carries its read date; stale facts are errors to correct, not proof of bad faith.
No criminal findingsWords like "fraud" or "scam" appear only inside attributed quotes or with final court/agency orders. We do not convict in prose.
No private persons, no private livesRegistry officials appear in public records; that is where our bio stops. We do not dig private lives for leverage or clicks.

05 // Independence & Conflicts of Interest

The Asset We Protect

We accept no advertising, no sponsored placements, no affiliate commissions, no referral fees, no lead-generation payments, and no discounts, freebies, or consideration of any kind from any company profiled or reviewed on this site. Ever. No profile, count, link, characterization or omission can be bought, rented, traded, requested or conditioned on anything.

Any revenue source adopted in the future will be published on this page before it begins, with the date, the basis, and which pages it could touch. That list is currently empty.

If a profiled company contacts us to request, demand, or offer anything related to its profile, the contact is logged, attributed to the company, and disclosed if material. Media inquiries from named sources are published as attributed quotes; everything else is ignored.

Our research team holds no carrier, broker or freight-forwarder authority. No author here dispatches trucks, brokers loads, sells leads, or operates an affiliate referral program. We have no financial interest in any company on reviews, and we never will in any company on reviews.

THE WHOLE POINT OF METHOD

A Mistake You Can Find, and a Path to Fix It

Every claim above is auditable against three free public links. If we got one wrong, the form, the evidence bar, the SLA and the public log live on one page:

Open corrections
Carfreight.review Research Desk · Methodology Rev. 2026-11 · November 2026