What The 2026 Data Actually Shows
- ·Open is the default. Published 2026 averages put a standard open shipment at roughly $914 (move.org), $1,150 (MoveAdvisor) and $1,215 (RoadRunner shipment data); SGT's first-party bands price a sedan by distance, dropping from about $2.04/mi under 500 miles to about $0.55/mi beyond 2,500 miles.
- ·Enclosed costs about 30-60% more on the same lane in every 2026 source we read. Move.org measured +47% ($1,342 enclosed vs $914 open). FreightWaves and ExtraSpace quote the same 30-60% band.
- ·Enclosed trailers carry fewer vehicles (2-7 hard-side units vs 8-10 on an open deck), which is why quotes scale with deck space, not with mileage alone.
- ·FMCSA does not certify enclosed as "safer" and does not set either price. It sets financial responsibility: brokers of property file $75,000 BMC-84 (or BMC-85); carriers file BMC-91X/BMC-34.
Choose Enclosed When
- ·The vehicle value exceeds what your deductible or carrier liability comfortably covers, or any paint/composite/chrome is irreplaceable.
- ·Low ground clearance: classics below 5", exotics, race cars, anything the driver cannot winch on an open deck ramp.
- ·Fresh restorations, concours entries, or anything being driven to a show within days of pickup.
- ·The route crosses heavy weather windows you cannot move out of.
Open Is Fine When
- ·Daily drivers, lease returns, crossovers, fleet cars, and commuter vehicles whose cosmetic risk is quantifiable and small.
- ·You have read the BOL and the carrier's cargo certificate; you know the actual coverage, deductible and claim window, in writing, before the truck shows up.
- ·Pickup is flexible enough that a day of slip does not cascade into missed work or a missed auction.
Before choosing, read the company's exact terms and its file on reviews, then check the quote against calculator and pricing. A quote far below either is a board price that will not clear, not a bargain.
What Actually Moves The Price
Distance dominates everything (about 70-80% of the variance in any published 2026 table), then season and access. Trailer class is a multiplier on top of that, not a floor under it. A quote that ignores lane, week and vehicle is marketing, not pricing.