CarFreight Review, independent auto transport research
HOME / JOURNAL / INDUSTRY STRUCTURE
GUIDE #STR-11 READ IN 8 MIN
INDUSTRY STRUCTURE GUIDE #STR-11

Auto transport broker or carrier?

Compare auto transport brokers and carriers before you pay a deposit.

Carfreight.review Research Desk PUBLISHED: NOVEMBER 15, 2026 UPDATED: NOVEMBER 15, 2026
$75,000
Broker bond required
BMC-84 or BMC-85, 49 U.S.C. § 13906
$750,000+
Property carrier liability
49 CFR Part 387
25 / 31
Our researched profiles
broker-operated entities
1,353
BBB complaint index
across 31 researched profiles
01 // EXECUTIVE SUMMARY What the evidence shows

Brokers arrange freight; carriers haul it. A broker's bond ($75,000) pays you if the broker fails; a carrier's liability policy pays for transit damage. The certificate in your driveway must name the driver and their MC, not the brokerage. Confusing them before you pay is the exact mechanism behind most non-refundable deposit disputes.

02 // The Difference, In One Sentence Each

BROKER

A property broker arranges transportation for you by negotiating with an actual motor carrier. Brokers never touch the car. They take a spread between what you pay and what the carrier accepts, and that spread is the broker's fee.

CARRIER

A motor carrier has the trucks, the drivers, the MC number, the bond, and the driver authority. It is the legal party actually moving your vehicle. Its liability policy covers your car in transit under Carmack Amendment terms.

Ask the company one question before paying: "Will your own truck, under your own MC, physically move my vehicle?" If the answer is "we work with a network of carriers", you are talking to a broker. That is not automatically bad, but it changes what you verify, what you sign, and who pays when things go wrong.

03 // What A Broker Owes You

  • ·Written disclosure of broker status before contract under 49 CFR § 371.7, usually in the estimate or first communication.
  • ·A $75,000 bond (BMC-84) or trust fund (BMC-85) on file. Verify it yourself on L&I before you pay.
  • ·Contract, not verbal. Every material term must be in writing, and your deposit must not become earned until the broker delivers on its side of the bargain.
  • ·No advance payment of carrier funds that strips leverage if the broker never assigns the load.

04 // What A Carrier Owes You

  • ·Active MC authority, listed on SAFER, with a status that is not "Record Inactive" or "Out of Service".
  • ·Proof of insurance, including cargo coverage, underwritten by a licensed U.S. or authorized foreign carrier, with your name as beneficiary or as filing location where practicable.
  • ·Driver qualification, via the carrier's MCS-150, including experience, safety rating, and inspection history on file at FMCSA.
  • ·Carmack Amendment as the liability frame for loss or damage in transit. It is not optional, it is the legal default for interstate carriage.
The broker's bond and the carrier's policy are two separate pools of money with two separate triggers. If the broker fails, the bond is your path; if the carrier damages your car, the cargo coverage is your path; if both fail, FCBA and small-claims court are your remaining levers.

05 // The Two Questions That Sort Out Which One You Are Talking To

  1. 1"What is your MC number and your USDOT number?" Then read SAFER: entity type, authority status, and MCS-150 date. If the company cannot produce the number, walk away.
  2. 2"Who is the driver and which trailer will carry my car?" A real carrier can name them; a broker cannot, because the driver does not exist yet. That is not bad; it is just true.

06 // What Our Profiles Show

Of the 31 companies we have profiled to this writing, 25 operate as FMCSA property brokers, 3 as carriers, and 3 as referral agents or marketplaces. In practice that means almost every online quote you will ever get comes from a broker hanging a listing on a private board, and your vehicle's dispatch rides on a match between a listing and a driver you have not met. That structure is legal under 49 CFR Part 371. It is not necessarily safe for you. The risk concentrates at the dispatch moment.

Carfreight.review Research Desk · GUIDE #STR-11 · November 2026