CarFreight Review, independent auto transport research
Company Research Profile // Independent Company Research · United States

Horseless Carriage Carriers: Reviews, Records & Company Research

Independent research on Horseless Carriage Carriers, a Paterson, New Jersey enclosed auto transporter and classic-car storage business that says it became part of McCollister’s in 2022. Last reviewed: November 15, 2026.

Company type Carrier (per website) Registration needs checking
Research status Public records reviewed Insurance filings open
USDOT // MC 805405 // MC-358185 Listed on the website
Authority Motor carrier Property and household goods
Research updated November 15, 2026 FMCSA data as of 11/13/2026
Company response None on file Right of reply open
shield Notice: Carfreight.review is independent and is not affiliated with Horseless Carriage Carriers. This profile is not a legal determination or an endorsement.
SECTION 01, Executive Summary

Executive Summary

This independent research profile examines Horseless Carriage Carriers, a company operating in the U.S. vehicle transportation industry. The review considers publicly available business information, federal regulatory records, published company policies, and consumer feedback. The findings reflect the sources available as of November 15, 2026 and do not constitute a legal determination or endorsement.

  • What we could verify. The website says the company joined McCollister’s on September 1, 2022 and lists USDOT 805405. FMCSA lists that number as an active carrier with property and household goods authority, 404 power units and a Satisfactory rating dated 2009.
  • What needs a closer look. Under the company’s own name, FMCSA shows a broker record (USDOT 2217862) with operating authority "NOT AUTHORIZED" and an older record (USDOT 163371) as inactive. This review could not confirm which registration performs and insures the work today. That is a question to put to the company, not a finding.
  • What consumers report. BBB lists no complaints, no reviews and no rating. Third-party reviews are mostly positive but come largely from before the 2022 sale, and the recent entries on one listing carry no weight here.
  • What is still open. Insurance filings, the written terms, deposit and claims rules, the "more than thirty" trucks claim, and how service has changed since 2022. A 2024 state labor settlement about driver classification is on the public record; the company denied wrongdoing.
SECTION 02, Company Overview

Company Overview

Legal entity, brand and website, kept separate

Company overview
ItemInformationSource
Legal name HORSELESS CARRIAGE CARRIERS INC (FMCSA record USDOT 2217862). BBB writes "Horseless Carriage Carriers,Inc". FMCSA SAFER
Official website horselesscarriage.com. Several pages were last edited in 2019 to 2021. The privacy and cookie pages were updated on July 2, 2026, so the site is maintained. horselesscarriage.com
Location 61 Iowa Avenue, Paterson, NJ 07503. The website describes a storage facility there, about 16 miles from New York City, and a headquarters about 18 miles from Port Newark/Elizabeth. Website / SAFER
Advertised services Enclosed vehicle transport for antique, classic, exotic and everyday vehicles, plus climate-controlled storage, manufacturer and auto-show logistics, and port and container services. The site also lists boats, airplanes, buses and military vehicles. Company / Services pages
Ownership The website footer says "Proudly part of the McCollister’s family since September 1st, 2022" and shows "USDOT #805405". nj.com reports the company was sold to McCollister’s Global Services in October 2022. The two dates differ and the exact McCollister’s entity involved was not established. A pop-up on the site’s pages also says visitors are being taken to an "Autotransport page, powered by McCollister’s". Website footer / nj.com
Business model The website describes the company as a carrier with its own fleet. Which FMCSA registration performs the transport is addressed in section 03. Company page
Dates the company and BBB give The website says "Since 1975", "more than 40 years" on the homepage and "more than 75 years in business" on the transport page. BBB lists a business start and incorporation date of January 1, 1974 and a BBB file opened February 6, 2003. These were not reconciled. Website / BBB
Size claims The company page says "a fleet of more than thirty tractor-trailer units". The page was edited in 2021, before the sale. Company page

Identity note. This profile covers the Paterson, NJ business at horselesscarriage.com. FMCSA, BBB and directories list several unrelated businesses with similar names (for example Horseless Carriages Inc in Michigan, Horseless Carriage Co in Connecticut and Horseless Carriage Transportation Inc in New York). Do not combine their records. It also shows McCollister’s FMCSA data because the website lists that USDOT number.

SECTION 03, FMCSA & Regulatory Records

FMCSA & Regulatory Records

Consulted November 15, 2026 · SAFER data as of 11/13/2026

Regulatory records
FieldInformationSource
Registration the website lists USDOT 805405, shown in the website footer next to "part of the McCollister’s family". Website
Legal name and DBA (USDOT 805405) MCCOLLISTER’S TRANSPORTATION SYSTEMS INC, doing business as MCCOLLISTER’S MOVING AND STORAGE INC FMCSA SAFER
USDOT / MC (805405) USDOT 805405 (Active; no out-of-service date). MC-358185. FMCSA SAFER
Classification and authority (805405) Carrier. Authorized as Motor Carrier of Property (Except Household Goods) and Motor Carrier of Household Goods. Interstate. Cargo carried includes motor vehicles and machinery. FMCSA SAFER
Address (805405) 8 Terri Lane, Burlington, NJ 08016. Phone (609) 864-2245. FMCSA SAFER
Fleet and mileage (805405) 404 power units, 384 drivers. MCS-150 dated 05/20/2026 reports 19,309,989 miles for 2025. These figures cover the whole McCollister’s registration, not only the Paterson operation. FMCSA SAFER
U.S. inspections, 24 months to 11/13/2026 (805405) 371 total. Vehicle: 208 inspections, 40 out of service (19.2%; national average 22.26%). Driver: 370 inspections, 10 out of service (2.7%; national average 6.67%). Hazmat: 2, none out of service. FMCSA SAFER
U.S. crashes, 24 months (805405) 12 reportable crashes: 1 fatal, 7 injury, 4 tow-away. SAFER notes crash entries show involvement and make no determination of responsibility. FMCSA SAFER
Safety rating (805405) Satisfactory. Rating date 09/01/2009, review date 08/05/2026, type shown as "Non-Ratable". FMCSA SAFER
Record under the company’s own name (USDOT 2217862) HORSELESS CARRIAGE CARRIERS INC, 61 Iowa Ave., Paterson, NJ. USDOT status Active, entity type Broker, MC-130693. Operating authority: NOT AUTHORIZED. Power units 0. No inspections or crashes in 24 months. FMCSA SAFER
Older record (USDOT 163371) SAFER shows "Record Inactive". FMCSA SAFER
Insurance and cargo filings Not located in the sources reviewed. The FMCSA Licensing & Insurance record was not read. The website says "fully-insured" and gives no amounts. FMCSA L&I (to be checked)
State labor matter In July 2024 New Jersey officials announced a settlement of wage-and-hour allegations that the company misclassified eight drivers as independent contractors from 2017 to 2019. nj.com reports total payments of $455,000, of which $364,000 goes to the workers. nj.com also reports the company denied any misclassification. nj.com

FMCSA classifies brokers and carriers differently, and a registration shows only the entity it names. Here the website lists one registration (805405) while a separate record under the company’s own name (2217862) is a broker record without authority. Ask the company which one will move your vehicle. See our guide on broker versus carrier and our consumer protection resources.

SECTION 04, Business Practices

Business Practices

Based on the company's website. Its terms were not available to this review.

Business practices
QuestionWhat the published materials saySource
Does it explain whether it is a broker or a carrier? The website describes enclosed-trailer transport with its own "tractor-trailer units". It does not name the FMCSA registration that holds authority except for the USDOT 805405 in the footer. The registration under its own name (2217862) is classified as a broker and shows no operating authority. Website / SAFER
Does it identify who performs the transport? The website says its drivers and trucks perform the work. It does not say which legal entity employs the drivers or holds the insurance after the 2022 sale. Company page
Are cancellation, deposit and refund terms published? Not located in the sources reviewed. A reviewer on a third-party site wrote "No upfront cost, no added fees" in 2021. The company’s own pages read do not state a deposit or a cancellation rule. Website
Are terms and conditions accessible? Not on the pages read. The website returned "page not found" for /terms-and-conditions and /about-us. A quote is requested through a form, and the site says the company will "follow up". Website
How are damage claims handled? Not located in the sources reviewed. The company describes its work as "safe, claim-free", which is a marketing claim. Company page
What insurance does it describe? The company says its fleet is "fully-insured". No amount, insurer or deductible is given on the pages read. Company page
Does it describe tracking? Yes. The gallery page says "GPS monitoring via GoPhore" with driver check-ins and milestone arrivals. The homepage footer says "We know exactly where your car is". The page date is 2020 and the tracking vendor may have changed. Gallery page
Does it explain how the price is set? No public prices. The transport page says "request a quote and we’ll follow up". Third-party reviewers describe the company as the most expensive of several carriers. Transport page
What does it say about privacy and personal data? A US privacy statement, last changed July 2, 2026, says it collects name, phone number and email through contact forms and keeps them until the service ends. It says it has not sold personal data or disclosed it for a business purpose in the past 12 months, honors Do Not Track, and may pass customer details to new owners if the company is sold. It offers access, deletion and export requests through a form or at 800.631.7796. The email address printed in the statement is malformed ("info@ex.comhorselesscarriage.com"). The cookie page lists Google Analytics, Cloudflare and WP Engine hosting. Privacy statement / Opt-out page
Does it describe storage terms? The storage page describes a "state-of-the-art" climate-controlled facility and a tailored plan. It does not state fees, insurance for stored cars or access rules. Storage page

Compare these answers with the Reliable Carriers profile, another enclosed carrier, and see our guides on classic car transport and damage claims.

SECTION 05, Consumer Feedback & Complaints

Consumer Feedback & Complaints

Three kinds of information, kept apart

A. Reviews on public platforms

  • BBB (Paterson, NJ profile): not accredited, "Not Rated" because BBB has insufficient information, 0 complaints, 0 customer reviews.
  • TransportRankings (user-submitted, unverified): 82 reviews averaging 4 out of 5, spanning 2009 to 2025. Older entries (2009 to 2022) include praise for careful handling and enclosed floors, a note that the price was the highest the reviewer was quoted, and one detailed 2011 complaint about repeated pickup reschedules and re-routing. The 2025 entries are brief and share very similar wording, so they were given no weight.
  • Company website: three testimonials selected by the company. They are undated.
  • Directory listings: one shows "BBB Rating: A+" while BBB’s page says "Not Rated". BBB was used.
  • Google, Trustpilot and ConsumerAffairs: not read in this edition.

B. Complaints filed with an identifiable organization

BBB lists 0 complaints for this company. The table is left in the template’s form to show that none were found, not that none exist elsewhere. Complaints to other bodies, such as state consumer agencies, were not searched in this edition.

BBB complaints
DateBBB typeWhat the complainant saidWhat the company saidStatus
n/a None on BBB BBB lists 0 complaints and 0 customer reviews for "Horseless Carriage Carriers,Inc" in Paterson, NJ. Not applicable. None

C. Experiences documented directly with us

None submitted to Carfreight.review as of November 15, 2026. Consumers can share documents through our contact page.

Recurring themes and limits

With no BBB complaints and no BBB reviews, there are no recurring consumer themes to report from independent, identifiable sources. The one detailed complaint in the sources read dates from 2011 and concerns pickup scheduling. That is too old and too narrow to describe the company today.

SECTION 06, Public Records & Documentation

Public Records & Documentation

What each document lets a reader verify

Public records
DocumentSourceDate consultedWhat it verifiesLimitations
FMCSA SAFER Snapshot, USDOT 805405 (McCollister’s Transportation Systems Inc) safer.fmcsa.dot.gov Nov 15, 2026 (data as of 11/13/2026) Entity type, authority, fleet, inspections, crashes, safety rating for the registration the website lists Covers all of McCollister’s, not only the Paterson operation. Does not show insurance.
FMCSA SAFER Snapshot, USDOT 2217862 (Horseless Carriage Carriers Inc) safer.fmcsa.dot.gov Nov 15, 2026 (data as of 11/13/2026) Broker classification and "NOT AUTHORIZED" status under the company’s own name Does not show whether another registration covers the work.
FMCSA SAFER, USDOT 163371 safer.fmcsa.dot.gov Nov 15, 2026 "Record Inactive" Relationship to the current company not established.
FMCSA Licensing & Insurance record li-public.fmcsa.dot.gov Not read Intended source for authority and insurance filings Open item for this edition.
Company homepage horselesscarriage.com Nov 15, 2026 Ownership statement, USDOT 805405, testimonials, tracking statement Marketing text. Several pages date from 2019 to 2021.
Privacy Statement (US) and Opt-out preferences (cookie policy) horselesscarriage.com Nov 15, 2026 Contact details, data collected, retention, sale of data, cookies and hosting. Both pages say they were last changed July 2, 2026. Company-published. The site pop-up on every page says "powered by McCollister’s". Not a shipping contract.
Company, Transport, Services and Gallery pages horselesscarriage.com Nov 15, 2026 History, fleet, services, manufacturer relationships, tracking Marketing text. Pre-sale statements.
BBB business profile bbb.org Nov 15, 2026 Not accredited, not rated, 0 complaints, 0 reviews, start dates BBB has insufficient information to rate. BBB does not verify what either side says.
nj.com report on the New Jersey labor settlement (July 2024) nj.com Nov 15, 2026 Settlement of wage-and-hour allegations, amounts, company denial, 2022 sale to McCollister’s Partly paywalled. The settlement agreement itself was not read.
TransportRankings listing transportrankings.com Nov 15, 2026 82 user-submitted reviews, average 4 out of 5, from 2009 to 2025 Unverified. The 2025 entries share very similar wording and were given no weight.
SECTION 07, Company Response

Company Response

Voluntary, free, and published in full

No statement on file · As of November 15, 2026

No response from Horseless Carriage Carriers is on file. Before this profile is indexed, the company will be invited to review the facts above, say which registration covers its transport, supply its terms and conditions, add documents and send a response. A lack of response is not an admission of any conduct.

Right of reply // Free

Are you a representative of this company?

Horseless Carriage Carriers can submit a response, provide documents, or request a correction at no cost and without buying any service. Responses are published in full and unedited next to the facts they address.

SECTION 08, Research Findings

Research Findings

No overall score: the method is not yet robust enough to support one

What we verified

  • The website says the company is "part of the McCollister’s family since September 1st, 2022" and shows USDOT 805405. nj.com reports a sale to McCollister’s Global Services in October 2022.
  • FMCSA lists USDOT 805405 as MCCOLLISTER’S TRANSPORTATION SYSTEMS INC, an active carrier with MC-358185, authorized for property and household goods, 404 power units and a Satisfactory rating dated 2009.
  • Under the company’s own name, FMCSA lists USDOT 2217862 as an active broker record with operating authority "NOT AUTHORIZED", and shows USDOT 163371 as inactive.
  • BBB lists the company as not accredited and not rated, with 0 complaints and 0 reviews.
  • New Jersey officials announced a 2024 settlement of wage-and-hour allegations about eight drivers, with $455,000 in total payments. The company denied misclassification.

What we could not verify

  • Which legal entity operates and insures the shipments today, and whether the 805405 inspection and crash figures describe the Paterson operation.
  • Insurance, cargo and process agent filings for any registration.
  • The company claims: "since 1975", "more than thirty" trucks, "fully-insured", "claim-free", and the manufacturer relationships.
  • Deposit, cancellation, refund and claims terms, which were not available.
  • How the company’s service has changed since the 2022 sale. Most website pages and the older reviews describe the period before it.
  • The settlement agreement itself, which was not read.

Before you decide

  • Ask which legal entity will move your vehicle, its USDOT and MC numbers, and who employs the driver.
  • Ask for the insurance certificate. Ask for the cargo limit, the deductible, and whether your vehicle’s agreed value is covered.
  • Ask for the written terms before you pay. Ask about any deposit, the cancellation rule and how claims work.
  • If you store a vehicle, ask for the storage contract: fees, insurance, access and what happens if payment is late.
  • Inspect the vehicle and note any damage on the Bill of Lading at pickup and delivery.
  • Do not rely on the older reviews alone. Many describe the company before it joined McCollister’s.
SECTION 09, Research Limitations

Research Limitations

What this research cannot show

  • The FMCSA Licensing & Insurance filings were not read, so insurance and process agent status are open.
  • The relationship between the Paterson company and the McCollister’s registration rests on the company’s own website footer and one news report. No ownership or authority document was read.
  • Inspection and crash figures for USDOT 805405 cover a large, separate fleet and are not evidence about the Paterson operation. Crash entries make no determination of fault.
  • The company’s terms, prices and deposit rules were not available.
  • Independent consumer feedback is very limited: BBB shows none, and the main review source is a user-submitted listing whose recent entries were given no weight. Google, Trustpilot and ConsumerAffairs were not read.
  • A directory listing shows "BBB Rating: A+" for this company, while BBB’s own page says "Not Rated". BBB’s page was used.
  • Other businesses share the name: Horseless Carriages Inc (MI), Horseless Carriage Co (CT), The Horseless Carriage (CA), Horseless Carriage Transportation Inc (NY limousine service), Horseless Carriage Inc Country Pride Motors (WI) and a former Kansas City dealer. They are separate and not covered here.
  • No archived copies of the pages have been stored yet. Pages can change after the date of consultation.
  • The company has not yet reviewed this profile, so its position on the facts above is unknown.
  • The research does not support conclusions about the company’s overall performance, intent, or whether any practice breaks the law. This is not a legal determination.
SECTION 10, Sources & Methodology

Sources & Methodology

Sources consulted November 15, 2026

Editorial criteria: federal and state records come first. Company statements are reported as the company's own. Consumer accounts are reported as accounts, not as facts. Anything we could not check is labeled "Not located in the sources reviewed". Read the full methodology, the corrections policy, or find other company profiles.

Commercial information // Business Intelligence & Research Services

Is your company ready for a deeper business review?

Our public research profiles focus on available records and documented information. Our separate business intelligence services provide companies with deeper analysis, benchmarking and strategic recommendations.

balance

Editorial independence. These services are separate from the research above. Buying one does not change, remove, delay or soften any public profile, and corrections and company responses are always free.

Business intelligence products
Product Deliverable Starting price
Company Intelligence Report Expanded research, documentation, analysis and an executive PDF From $500
Reputation & Visibility Audit Audit of reputation, digital presence and improvement opportunities From $750
Monthly Monitoring Periodic tracking of public and regulatory changes From $299/mo
Industry Intelligence Sector comparison and competitor analysis From $499/mo

Introductory starting prices. The final quote depends on scope.

What happens next

  1. 01You receive a confirmation of your request.
  2. 02We review the request and check that the scope is feasible.
  3. 03You receive a commercial proposal. There is no obligation to accept it.